Medical ethics for US interviews
Four principles, US law and worked MMI scenarios
Ethics questions test how you reason, not which side you pick. Name the principles in tension: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence or justice. Then use the law correctly. Much of it sits with the states: 13 states and DC allowed medical aid in dying as of September 2026, and abortion law has been set state by state since 2022. Finish by committing to a clear next step.
- Aid in dying legal
- 13 states and DC (Sept 2026)
- Abortion law
- State by state since Dobbs
- Health privacy
- HIPAA, plus stricter state law
- Emergency care
- EMTALA, federal since 1986
- In this guide
- 8 worked scenarios
Photo: King of Hearts · CC BY-SA 4.0 · cropped
Photo: Rehua · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Photo: Warren LeMay from Cullowhee, NC, United States · CC0 · Photo: Raf2016 · CC BY-SA 4.0
The habit that helps most: ask whether the law is federal or state
An ethics question is not a test of your politics. In an MMI (multiple mini interview), a Casper scenario or a traditional interview, you are showing how you think.
American health law is a thin federal layer over many state systems. HIPAA and EMTALA are federal. Most contested questions, such as aid in dying, abortion, minors' consent and the duty to warn, sit largely with the states. So before you say the law says, ask which law.
| Topic | Main source | Federal or state |
|---|---|---|
| Health privacy | HIPAA Privacy Rule, 45 CFR Part 164 | Federal floor. More stringent state privacy laws still apply (45 CFR 160.203). |
| Emergency care | EMTALA, section 1867 of the Social Security Act | Federal, for Medicare-participating hospitals that offer emergency services |
| How much to disclose for consent | State laws and court decisions | State |
| Who decides when a patient cannot | State surrogate rules | State, plus a federal duty on advance directives (42 USC 1395cc) |
| Minors' consent | State law | State. HIPAA then follows state law on parents' access (45 CFR 164.502). |
| Duty to warn or protect | Tarasoff (California, 1976) and each state's law | State |
| Aid in dying | State statutes, and a court ruling in Montana | State. The Supreme Court found no constitutional right (Glucksberg, 1997). |
| Abortion | State law since Dobbs (2022) | State, with an open federal question on emergencies |
| Conscience in funded programs | Church Amendments, 42 USC 300a-7 | Federal |
| Organ allocation | 42 CFR 121.8 and 42 USC 274e | Federal |
The four principles of medical ethics, and how they collide
The four principles are not ranked. The work of ethics is to weigh them in one specific case, which is why interviewers build scenarios where two collide.
Autonomy
A patient with capacity may decide about their own body, including decisions you think unwise. US ethics weighs this heavily, partly because of abuses such as the Tuskegee study (1932 to 1972), where the CDC says researchers took no informed consent and offered no treatment, even after penicillin became widely available.
Beneficence
You act for the patient's benefit. This collides most often with autonomy, when the helpful course is the one the patient refuses.
Non-maleficence
You avoid harm and keep harms in proportion to benefits. This collides with beneficence in any treatment that helps by injuring, such as surgery or chemotherapy. The patient's values help decide what counts as proportionate.
Justice
You distribute benefits, risks and costs fairly, and treat people fairly. Justice sits behind questions about who gets a scarce organ, and whether someone without insurance gets care at all.
How to answer an ethics question: five steps for a short station
Clarify
Say what you would need to know, and why it would change your answer. Does the patient have capacity? Which state are we in? Is this an emergency?
Name the tension
Name the principles in conflict in one plain sentence, then move on. Do not define them unless asked.
Consider who is affected
Think about the patient, their family, you, your team, other patients and the public. Do not stop at the patient.
Weigh the options
Give at least two courses of action and the strongest argument for each, including the one you do not favor.
Decide and justify
Commit. Say what you would do, why, and what would change your mind. Say who you would ask for help, such as a supervisor or ethics committee.
Free PDF
Take the Ultimate Medical Ethics Guide (US) with you as a PDF
Prefer to study on paper? Enter your email and we will send you the US medical ethics guide as a free PDF.
- A printable copy to annotate as you study
- Handy for practicing scenarios away from a screen
- Free, sent straight to your inbox

Get instant access to your free guide
Enter your email and your The Ultimate Medical Ethics Guide (US) downloads straight away. We also email you a link so you can download it again on any device.
Informed consent and capacity: what the law and the codes say
Informed consent is a process, not a signature. The AMA's Code of Medical Ethics (Opinion 2.1.1) treats it as fundamental in both ethics and law. UW's bioethics department lists what the discussion covers: the decision, reasonable alternatives, the risks, benefits and uncertainties of each, what the patient understands, and the patient's acceptance.
How much must you disclose? It depends on the state. Under the reasonable physician standard, you say what a typical physician would say. Under the reasonable patient standard, you say what the average patient would need to decide. Canterbury v. Spence (D.C. Circuit, 1972) is the leading case for the second: it made the test whether a risk is material to the patient's decision. UW says most states set their standard by statute or case law, and that Washington uses the reasonable patient standard.
Capacity is not competence
Capacity is a clinical judgment about one decision at one time. Competence is a legal finding, made in court. UW describes capacity as intact when the patient understands the information, appreciates their situation and the consequences, can reason about their choices, and can clearly communicate a choice. A refusal does not by itself show that capacity is missing, because competent patients may refuse even lifesaving treatment.
When a patient lacks capacity, AMA Opinion 2.1.2 asks you to involve them as far as they are able and to identify an appropriate surrogate. A surrogate is someone who decides on their behalf. Follow any valid advance directive first. After that, UW says the law recognizes a hierarchy of family relationships, and the order depends on the state.
| A life-threatening emergency | If the patient cannot consent and there is no time to find a surrogate without harm, you may treat. Check for known wishes where you can. |
|---|---|
| Dentistry | ADA Code section 1.A says to inform the patient of the proposed treatment and any reasonable alternatives, so they can take part in decisions. |
Minors: who consents, and what parents can see
Parents usually decide for young children, guided by the child's best interests. UW says clinicians should challenge decisions that put a child at significant risk of serious harm, first through discussion and ethics consultation, then through child protection services if needed. Prince v. Massachusetts (1944) is the classic Supreme Court statement: rights of religion and parenthood have limits, and the state's authority does not vanish because a parent's objection rests on religion.
Older children should have a voice, even when a parent has final authority. A minor can also have legal authority to decide in three situations, all set by state law.
| Situation | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| Emancipated minor | Every state has a law. Most recognize a minor who is self-supporting and not living at home, married, a parent or on active duty in the armed services. |
| Mature minor | Some states let certain minors decide as mature minors, and how far varies. UW says it usually means someone older than 14 with adult-like understanding, and that most states need a court to find it. |
| Condition-specific laws | All states make exceptions to parental consent for some conditions, which may include sexually transmitted infections, pregnancy, contraception, psychiatric disorders and drug or alcohol problems. |
| Care | State law |
|---|---|
| STI testing and treatment | All 50 states and DC allow minors to consent, though eight set a minimum age. 16 states have rules on telling parents, some only in certain cases. |
| Contraception | 23 states and DC explicitly allow minors to consent. 16 more allow it under specific circumstances. 2 states bar access without a parent's consent. |
| Abortion | 37 states require a parent's consent, notice or both. That count includes the 13 total-ban states, where these laws generally apply only to exceptions. 36 have a judicial bypass, which lets a court approve instead. |
Guttmacher is a research group that supports abortion rights. We use only its counts. Check the state you are discussing.
HIPAA follows that law. Under 45 CFR 164.502(g), a parent is normally a minor's personal representative. When a minor lawfully consents on their own, the parent generally is not, for that care. Whether a parent can then see those records depends on state law. So the honest interview answer begins with: I would check my state's law.
In an emergency, UW says a child can be treated without a parent's permission if the guardian is unavailable and delay would endanger the child.
Confidentiality and HIPAA in plain words
Applicants often overstate HIPAA. Its Privacy Rule applies to covered entities: health plans, health care clearinghouses and providers who send health information electronically in covered transactions (45 CFR 160.103). It does not regulate everyone who holds health information. Your ethical duty of confidentiality is wider than the rule, so do not treat HIPAA as the whole of it.
| Situation | What the rule says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Talking to the consulting specialist | Allowed without separate authorization. Treatment, payment and health care operations are permitted uses. | 45 CFR 164.506 |
| A serious threat to someone | Allowed when needed to prevent or lessen a serious and imminent threat to a person or the public. | 45 CFR 164.512(j) |
| Suspected child abuse | Allowed to the authority that receives these reports. State law often makes reporting mandatory. | 45 CFR 164.512(b) |
| Reportable infections | Allowed for public health reporting. UW notes that state law requires reports of certain infectious diseases. | 45 CFR 164.512(b) |
| A stricter state law | The state law stands where it is more stringent about privacy. | 45 CFR 160.203 |
Tarasoff v. Regents (California Supreme Court, 1976) is the case to know. A patient told a university therapist he intended to kill Tatiana Tarasoff. She was not warned, and he killed her. The court held that when a therapist determines, or should determine, that a patient presents a serious danger of violence to another, the therapist must use reasonable care to protect the intended victim. That can mean warning the victim, telling the police or other steps.
Tarasoff is California law about therapists, and California has since narrowed it. Civil Code 43.92 limits a psychotherapist's liability to a communicated serious threat against a reasonably identifiable victim, and reasonable efforts to warn the victim and law enforcement discharge the duty. Other states have their own rules, so say that it varies.
UW offers a useful test: will not having this specific information put a person or group you can identify at high risk of serious harm? If not, an exception is unlikely to be warranted. Without the patient's permission, sharing with an inquiring spouse is generally not justified either. Start by asking the patient to share or to agree to it.
End of life: refusing treatment, hospice and medical aid in dying by state
A competent adult may refuse life-sustaining treatment. In Cruzan v. Director (1990), the Supreme Court said a competent person has a liberty interest in refusing unwanted treatment, and that Missouri could require clear and convincing evidence of an incompetent patient's wishes. That is why written wishes matter.
Federal law backs this up. 42 USC 1395cc(f) requires participating hospitals, nursing facilities, home health agencies and hospices to tell adults in writing about their state-law rights to refuse treatment and make advance directives. They must also record whether a patient has one.
| Withholding and withdrawing treatment | UW says there is no ethical distinction between not starting a treatment and stopping it, and that courts have found both equally justifiable. |
|---|---|
| Hospice | A Medicare benefit for people certified as terminally ill, with a life expectancy of 6 months or less, who accept comfort care instead of care to cure. |
| Palliative sedation | Sedating an imminently dying patient, whose suffering nothing else relieves, to the point of unconsciousness. UW treats this as separate from aid in dying. |
| Medical aid in dying | A clinician the state allows prescribes the medication, usually a physician. Some states, such as Washington, also allow physician assistants and nurse practitioners. The patient decides whether and when to take it, and must self-administer. |
| Euthanasia | A third party gives the medication or acts directly to end the patient's life. UW says this is illegal in every state. |
Medical aid in dying: the law by state
The Constitution leaves this to the states. Washington v. Glucksberg (1997) upheld a state's ban on assisting suicide. Vacco v. Quill (1997) upheld New York's, accepting a distinction between refusing lifesaving treatment and assisted suicide. States have since gone different ways.
| Jurisdiction | How it became legal | In effect |
|---|---|---|
| Oregon | Death with Dignity Act, approved by voters in 1994 | October 27, 1997 |
| Washington | Death with Dignity Act, approved by voters in 2008 | March 5, 2009 |
| Montana | Court ruling, Baxter v. Montana, 2009. There is no statute. | Since the ruling |
| Vermont | Act 39, signed in 2013 | May 20, 2013 |
| California | End of Life Option Act, signed in 2015 | June 9, 2016 |
| Colorado | End of Life Options Act, approved by voters in 2016 | December 16, 2016 |
| District of Columbia | Death with Dignity Act, signed in 2016 | February 18, 2017 |
| Hawaii | Our Care, Our Choice Act, signed in 2018 | January 1, 2019 |
| New Jersey | Aid in Dying for the Terminally Ill Act, signed in 2019 | August 1, 2019 |
| Maine | Death with Dignity Act, signed in 2019 | September 19, 2019 |
| New Mexico | Elizabeth Whitefield End of Life Options Act, signed in 2021 | June 18, 2021 |
| Delaware | Ron Silverio/Heather Block End of Life Options Act, signed in 2025 | January 1, 2026 |
| New York | Medical Aid in Dying Act, signed in 2026 | August 5, 2026 |
| Illinois | End-of-Life Options for Terminally Ill Patients Act, signed in 2025 | September 12, 2026 |
From Death with Dignity, an advocacy group. Its state map was current as of September 12, 2026, and its pages then showed federal suits pending against Illinois's law and repeal efforts aimed at DC and New Jersey. Check before your interview.
These laws share a shape, with local differences. Oregon's is the original. The Oregon Health Authority says a patient must be 18 or older, capable of making and communicating health care decisions, and have a terminal illness that will lead to death within six months. They make two oral requests at least 15 days apart and a written request signed before two witnesses. Since 2020, patients with less time to live can be exempt from the wait. They take the medication themselves.
The profession is divided. AMA Opinion 5.7 opposes physician-assisted suicide. It also accepts that a physician who legally takes part, after due moral consideration and in good conscience, has not violated the Code. Be ready to give both sides fairly.
Arguments often made for
- It respects the autonomy of a capable, dying person.
- A physician's duty to relieve suffering can justify it.
- Patients on life support can already refuse treatment, and treating like cases alike favors an option for others.
- Legal rules bring open discussion to something that may otherwise happen in secret.
Arguments often made against
- It runs counter to the traditional duty to preserve life and do no harm.
- People who are poor, disabled or elderly may feel pushed toward it.
- Safeguards may not catch every case of coercion.
- Linking it to medicine could harm trust in the profession.
Abortion and conscience: how an interviewer may raise them
We take no position on abortion, and a strong answer does not depend on holding any particular view. The interviewer is testing whether you can reason fairly and keep your personal views apart from your professional duties.
In Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022), the Supreme Court held that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion. It overruled Roe and Casey and returned the authority to regulate abortion to the people and their elected representatives. The law now depends on the state.
The Guttmacher Institute, a research group that supports abortion rights, counted 13 states with a total ban as of September 17, 2026. Another 28 had a ban tied to how far the pregnancy had progressed, and 9 states plus DC had no such limit. Bans usually carry limited exceptions, whose wording differs by state. These counts predate the November 2026 ballot measures, which may change the picture, so check Guttmacher's current map before your interview.
Emergencies: an open federal question
EMTALA requires Medicare-participating hospitals that offer emergency services to screen and stabilize patients with emergency conditions. In Moyle v. United States (2024), the Court took up whether EMTALA preempts Idaho's abortion law, then dismissed the case without deciding it. CMS rescinded its 2022 guidance on the question in June 2025 and says it still enforces EMTALA. If asked, say the question is unresolved.
Conscience: what the law and the code say
The Church Amendments (42 USC 300a-7) protect individuals in covered federally funded programs who decline to take part in abortion or sterilization because of religious beliefs or moral convictions. Subsection (e) also bars funded entities from discriminating against applicants for training, including residency, because of their reluctance or their willingness to take part. The protection runs in both directions.
AMA Opinion 1.1.7 sets out the professional side. Physicians should make clear, before entering a relationship with a patient, any specific services they cannot provide in good conscience. They should inform the patient about all relevant options, including those they object to, and in general refer the patient elsewhere when they decline.
Those who support access often stress
- A patient's authority over their own body and health decisions
- Safety when a pregnancy threatens health
- The unequal effect of bans on people who cannot travel
Those who oppose abortion often stress
- The moral status of the fetus
- A duty to protect life at every stage
- The conscience of clinicians who object to taking part
Resource allocation: organs, ventilators and who gets care
Rationing means sharing out something in short supply by rules meant to be fair. UW's bioethics department gives the classic warning. In 1962, a Seattle committee choosing who would get dialysis first looked at likely medical benefit, then at social worth: what each patient might contribute to society. It led to discriminatory judgments, favoring the popular, the educated and the devout. Name that history, then use better criteria.
| Criterion | The question it asks | How it holds up |
|---|---|---|
| Medical benefit | Who is likely to benefit? | A common first test. Seattle's committee started here. |
| Urgency | Who gets worse fastest without it? | Federal organ rules rank candidates from most to least medically urgent, using objective criteria where possible. |
| Time waiting | Who has waited longest? | UW lists it among transplant criteria. It can favor people who reached care early. |
| Quality of life | Whose life is better? | Ask who is judging. UW says physicians often rate a patient's quality of life lower than the patient does. |
| Social worth | Who matters most to society? | The Seattle lesson: it invites discrimination. Do not rely on it. |
| Ability to pay | Who can afford it? | Organs cannot be bought. 42 USC 274e makes transfer for valuable consideration unlawful, while allowing payment of a donor's expenses. |
Organ allocation has its own federal rule. 42 CFR 121.8 says policies must rest on sound medical judgment and must not depend on where a candidate lives or is listed, except where other parts of the rule require it.
In a disaster, the usual rules can shift. The Institute of Medicine's 2009 letter report gives guidance on crisis standards of care, for use by public health officials and health care facilities when resources are scarce. UW describes triage as seeing first those whose condition needs immediate attention. In a mass disaster, it says, priorities may differ.
Access is the wider justice question. EMTALA, enacted in 1986, requires Medicare-participating hospitals that offer emergency services to screen and stabilize people regardless of ability to pay. It reaches emergencies only, not the follow-up care that might have kept someone out of the emergency room.
Dental ethics: the ADA Code's five principles
Dental applicants meet the same dilemmas, plus some of their own around cost and elective treatment. The ADA's Principles of Ethics and Code of Professional Conduct adds veracity to the four principles above. The AAMC's Premed Competencies are written for medical schools, so do not frame a dental answer around them.
| Principle | An example from the Code | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Patient autonomy | Inform the patient of proposed treatment and reasonable alternatives, and safeguard the confidentiality of records. | 1.A, 1.B |
| Nonmaleficence | Do not practice while impaired by alcohol or drugs. Urge impaired colleagues to seek treatment, and report first-hand knowledge to a dental society's professional assistance committee. | 2.D |
| Beneficence | Do good, including through service to the community. | 3.A |
| Justice | Do not refuse patients because of race, creed, color, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin or disability. | 4.A |
| Veracity | Be truthful. Recommending or performing unnecessary services is unethical, whatever your practice arrangement. | 5.B.6 |
Eight worked MMI-style ethics scenarios for medicine and dentistry
We wrote these scenarios ourselves. Try each one out loud before you read what a strong answer does.
A 45-year-old Jehovah's Witness is bleeding after surgery. She is alert, understands she could die and refuses a blood transfusion. Her husband begs you to give one. What do you do?
A strong answer checks capacity properly, without doubting it just because you disagree. If she has capacity, her refusal stands: Cruzan recognizes a competent person's liberty interest in refusing treatment. It speaks with her alone, to be sure the choice is hers, asks which blood-free options she accepts and treats everything else fully. It is kind to her husband, who cannot overrule her.
- Principles: autonomy against beneficence.
- Involve senior colleagues and record the conversation.
- It changes if she loses capacity: look for an advance directive and her known wishes.
A 16-year-old asks for an STI test and says her parents must not know. The next day her mother calls the clinic and asks why she came in. What do you do?
A strong answer starts with the law: Guttmacher reports that all 50 states and DC let minors consent to STI testing and treatment. If she lawfully consented, HIPAA generally does not make her mother her personal representative for that care, and state law governs what a parent can see. So it does not confirm details to the mother. It encourages the teen to involve a trusted adult, without forcing her.
- Say you would check your state's rule on telling parents.
- Screen for pressure or abuse. Mandatory reporting applies if you suspect it.
- Principles: autonomy and beneficence.
A patient tells you he plans to hurt his former partner tonight, and he names her. He asks you to keep it secret. What do you do?
A strong answer treats this as a recognized exception. It assesses how serious and imminent the threat is, and tries to get the patient to agree to safety steps. HIPAA allows disclosure needed to prevent a serious and imminent threat (45 CFR 164.512(j)). Tarasoff and California's later statute bind psychotherapists, and other states vary, so it says which rule it means. It involves a supervisor, then warns her or calls the police.
- Tell the patient what you are doing, if that is safe.
- Share only what is needed.
- Principles: non-maleficence toward her against confidentiality toward him.
You are a student on a rotation. You smell alcohol on your resident's breath just before a procedure. What do you do?
Patient safety comes first if the risk is immediate, so a strong answer raises it with the attending straight away. It separates what you noticed from what you assume, speaks to the resident if that is safe, and uses the proper channel. It frames reporting as a route to help: state physician health programs exist to support health in the profession. The ADA Code is explicit for dentists: urge treatment and report.
- Two opposite mistakes: covering for a friend, and going over everyone's head without checking your facts.
- Principles: non-maleficence toward patients, and beneficence toward your colleague.
A patient with terminal cancer, in a state that allows medical aid in dying, asks you to help her end her life. You are unsure how you feel about it. What do you say?
A strong answer first asks why she is asking. Pain, fear, depression or feeling like a burden may be treatable, so it offers palliative care and checks capacity. If she still wants to proceed, state law sets the steps. Oregon's include two oral requests 15 days apart and a written request. If you object, you can say so, but you still help her find someone who can lawfully discuss it.
- Name the split in the profession: AMA Opinion 5.7, and the laws of 13 states and DC.
- Principles: autonomy, beneficence and non-maleficence.
An interviewer asks: would you perform an abortion, and what would you do if a patient asked you about one?
A strong answer separates two questions. Your personal view is yours, and you can share it briefly or keep it private. Your professional duties do not change either way: know your state's law, give accurate information about all relevant options, follow the AMA's guidance to refer in general if you decline, and never shame a patient. It also treats colleagues who decide differently with respect.
- Say that emergencies need immediate care, and that EMTALA's reach here is unresolved.
One ventilator is left. Two patients need it: a 40-year-old parent of three with a good chance of recovery, and a 78-year-old retired nurse with a lower chance. Who gets it?
A strong answer refuses to rank them by social worth: being a parent or a nurse is not the test. It starts with likely medical benefit and urgency, and uses the hospital's triage or crisis policy if there is one. It asks the senior team or a triage committee to decide, so no one person carries it alone. The other patient still gets comfort care and honest talk with family.
- Ask first about alternatives, such as transfer or another machine.
- Say age alone is a poor stand-in for likely benefit.
- Principles: justice against beneficence.
A patient with healthy front teeth asks for six veneers to improve her smile. Your practice owner reminds you that the practice needs the income. What do you do?
A strong answer separates what she wants, what she needs and what the practice wants. It explains the risks, benefits and less invasive alternatives, as ADA Code section 1.A requires. If she understands and still wants veneers, it weighs her choice against harm to healthy teeth, and you may decline treatment you judge harmful. The income target changes nothing: section 5.B.6 calls recommending unnecessary services unethical.
- Principles: autonomy, nonmaleficence and veracity.
- Record the discussion, and suggest a second opinion if you decline.
Common mistakes in medical and dental ethics questions
Medical ethics for US interviews: your questions answered
Where this guide's facts come from
Checked against these sources on November 9, 2026. Rules change between cycles, so confirm anything that decides your application on the official page for your entry year.
Practice ethics out loud before the real thing
Reading the law is the easy part. A mock interview tests whether you can structure a dilemma, use the facts correctly and decide under time pressure.



