Capacity Dispute Between Patient and Family
Answer timer
8:00/ 8 min suggested
Answer the question
Answer out loud against the clock, or type your key points.
Capacity Dispute Between Patient and Family
An 82-year-old woman with mild cognitive impairment has decided to refuse a recommended hip replacement after a fall. Her son is furious — he insists she lacks capacity, that "she'd agree if she understood", and demands you proceed against her wishes. How do you handle the conversation with the family while protecting the patient?
- 1What are the four functional elements of capacity, and how do you assess them in this scenario?
- 2Why is "she'd agree if she understood" not a basis for overriding refusal?
- 3How do you keep the son engaged as a future support person rather than alienating him?
Speak it out loud and we'll type it for you (free), or type your own notes — then mark yourself below.
- SPIKES for breaking bad news: Setting, Perception, Invitation, Knowledge, Empathy, Strategy.
- Listen → empathise → check understanding → agree a plan together. Calm voice, no jargon.
What strong answers doReveal the benchmark
Hidden so they don't bias your answer. Score yourself first, then reveal them to compare.
- Capacity has four functional elements (understand, retain, weigh, communicate), is decision-specific, and is not removed by mild cognitive impairment; assess and document each element, and if capacity is present the refusal stands.
- "She'd agree if she understood" inverts the test: the question is whether she understands enough to decide, not whether she would reach her son's preferred outcome. An unwise choice is not evidence of incapacity.
- Keep the son engaged: acknowledge his fear, ask what worries him, explain (with her consent) what she has weighed, and give him a practical role, while never re-assessing capacity just because the family dislikes the answer.
Mark yourself
Score each skill against the question's mark scheme, then add a line of evidence.
Ethics
Look for: Protects right to make unwise decisions, distinguishes functional capacity from outcome agreement
Communication
Look for: Keeps the family engaged while protecting the patient
Healthcare Knowledge
Look for: Accurate on the four functional elements of capacity
Insight
Look for: Recognises that today's family relationship is tomorrow's safety net
Reflect & score
Note what you'd change, then give the whole answer a mark out of 10.
Your overall score / 10
Not scored yet
Your results
Mark yourself first, then reveal the model answer to compare.
Your score, charted against a model answer
- Score ring and verdict
- Skills radar, you vs the model
- Strongest skill and next step
- Checks on your wording