MCAT and GPA
Penn's class MCAT is 522 (median) and Pitt's is 521 (median), both confirmed on the schools' own published figures. A 1-point gap is small, and says little about who is admitted at either.
Penn's class GPA is 3.98 (median) and Pitt's is 3.97 (median), both confirmed on the schools' own published figures.
A class figure is a benchmark, not a minimum: it describes who enrolled, and half of a class scored below its median.